Text Messages Reveal Top Fox News Hosts Privately Referring to Trump Team’s Election Fraud Claims as ‘Insane’

Text messages made public through a court hearing on Thursday show some of the Fox News Network’s top hosts decrying former President Donald Trump’s advisers and their election fraud claims as “insane.”

The correspondence and testimony were made available as part of an ongoing $1.6 billion defamation lawsuit filed by Dominion Voting System against Fox News.

“Sidney Powell is lying by the way. I caught her. It’s insane,” Tucker Carlson said in text message to Laura Ingraham, scarcely two weeks after the election.

Powell, along with Rudy Giuliani, were two of Trump’s top lawyers who filed election challenges on the former President’s behalf, and they are part of the lawsuit.

“Sidney is a complete nut,” Ingraham replied. “No one will work with her. Ditto with Rudy.”

Carlson remarked that their claims were putting hosts in a difficult spot because their best intentions were leading them to believe what some of Trump’s team were alleging.

“Our viewers are good people and they believe it,” he wrote.

Related: Tucker Carlson Blasts Fox News For Cutting Away From Trump Press Conference On Alleged Voter Fraud

Fox News Hosts, Execs Dismissed Election Fraud Claims

Further text messages showed the hosts felt they were in a quandary – they personally believed the claims to be false but wanted their viewers to decide as opposed to openly rebuking the allegations being put forth.

Carlson referenced a tweet by reporter Jacqui Heinrich which fact-checked a tweet by Trump criticizing the network coverage. Heinrich argued there was no evidence of voter fraud from Dominion.

“Please get her fired,” Carlson said in a message to Sean Hannity. “It needs to stop immediately, like tonight. It’s measurably hurting the company. The stock price is down. Not a joke.”

Previous testimony by Hannity has him declaring he “did not believe it for one second” in regard to statements by Powell that Dominion machines were being used “to trash large batches of votes.”

Proving defamation will be a difficult burden for Dominion, as The New York Times reports that they must prove “hosts and executives knew what was being said on the air was false and allowed it anyway.”

This is an incredibly slippery slope considering opinion hosts at other networks like CNN and MSNBC surely know many of their guests are lying on certain subject matters.

If Trump were to sue CNN over the Hunter Biden laptop story, would the phones and devices of those network hosts be seized in discovery? Would they be held responsible for someone like James Clapper hinting that it was ‘Russian disinformation’?

Related: Trump Campaign Slams Fox News Director Who Called Arizona For Biden: ‘A Clinton-Voting, Biden-Donating Democrat’

Carlson Criticized Fox News

Carlson took a swipe at his own network when colleague Neil Cavuto cut away from a press conference held by Kayleigh McEnany and RNC Chairwoman Ronna McDaniel regarding alleged voter fraud in November of 2020.

McEnany claimed that the Trump campaign “want(s) every legal vote to be counted, and we want every illegal vote …” before Cavuto interjected.

“Whoa, whoa, whoa – I just think we have to be very clear,” he said. “She’s charging the other side as welcoming fraud and welcoming illegal voting.”

“Unless she has more details to back that up, I can’t in good countenance continue to show you this.”

Carlson took a subtle jab at Cavuto and his own network for making the decision to cut away from McEnany.

“In a democracy, you can’t ignore honest questions from citizens,” Carlson said.

“You can’t dismiss them out of hand as crazy or immoral for asking,” he continued. “You can’t just cut away from coverage you don’t like.”

Carlson had also been critical of Fox News for what some supporters of Trump had considered a premature call of Arizona in favor of Joe Biden on election night, 2020.

“I’m not privy to the math, I’m not certain how, even after the explanation from Chris Stirewalt, how that decision was made,” Carlson criticized. “I think our viewers trust us, but people are concerned.”

If this lawsuit succeeds, and the new standard for journalists or opinion show hosts is that you can’t air anything you personally believe to be false, there would be nothing to report on.

Rusty Weiss

Rusty Weiss is a freelance writer focusing on the conservative movement and its political agenda. He has been following and analyzing the political climate for several years, and his writings have appeared in the Daily Caller, FoxNews.com and more.

View Comments

  • Last thing I ever watched on Faux News was calling AZ for Biden WAY before every other network. Cut my cable the next day. Will NEVER watch them again.

  • So, Fox wanted its viewers to "decide for themselves" while giving them one-sided news? Yep. That's how it's done. Fox, just like this site, delights in seeing how gullible its readers and viewers are while the cynical, highly-paid hosts make fun of them. Hey, don't be mad at me. You just saw for yourself what they do.

  • As a voter in 2020, I went to the polls on election day, but because I was suffering from
    COVID and not feeling well, I took my ballet and placed it in a box. The next morning I received a Thank You Not from the Governor congratulating me for voting for Biden. Please do not tell me that Trump was wrong. Upon investigation, I discovered that hundreds/thousands of us in this county had our votes stolen and given to Biden. Hannity, Tucker you are wrong.

  • Look like all of Fox News show are afraid of losing their jobs! So they do as Paul Ryan demand them if they want to stay at Falling News!

  • At first blush it did seem insane, but after thinking about how Biden ran his "campaign" from his basement, never/rarely speaking about what he would do as President and seeing the results of 2+ years of absolute failure combined with what is now known about the Biden Crime Family . . . . . Trump was right.

  • Stolen elections, Treason, voter fraud, cover ups, censorship, entrapment, etc etc has its consequences.

    2020 election was stolen and America is rejecting the rinos who aided and abetted the dirty dems.

Recent Posts

New January 6 Capitol Riot Security Videos Show Pelosi’s Daughter Filming Evacuation For Documentary

Newly released January 6th security footage at the Capitol shows Nancy Pelosi's daughter continuing to…

21 hours ago

Jen Psaki Claims Republicans ‘Comfortable’ With Biden Because He’s an Old White Guy

Former White House press secretary Jen Psaki argued that many Republicans are actually "comfortable" with…

22 hours ago

Federal Agents Seize Ton of Fentanyl in Arizona, Enough to Kill 453 Million People

By Bethany Blankley (The Center Square) With an unknown volume of fentanyl and other drugs…

23 hours ago

Alabama Governor Kay Ivey Corrects Woke ESPN: I Banned ‘Biological Men’ From Women’s Sports, Not ‘Transgender Women’

Alabama Governor Kay Ivey roasted the former sports network ESPN with a tweet correcting their…

23 hours ago

More States Move to Ban Chinese Purchase of Farmland

By Kim Jarrett (The Center Square) Several states have already banned or are considering banning…

1 day ago

Trump Brutalizes Chris Christie for Running Against Him in 2024: ‘What’s The Purpose?’

Donald Trump taunted his GOP rivals for being so far behind in the polls and…

1 day ago