Judge Shuts Down Gavin Newsom – Rules He Overstepped Authority On Mail-In Ballots

California’s Democratic Governor Gavin Newsom got some bad news on Friday when a judge ruled that he overstepped his legal authority by mandating that every legal voter in his state receive a mail-in ballot for the general election. This ruling reportedly will have no impact on the 2020 election.

Newsom’s Executive Order

Back in June, Newsom issued an executive order declaring that “all Californians who are registered (and otherwise eligible) to vote in the November 3, 2020 General Election shall receive vote-by-mail ballots.” This order was issued as part of the California Emergency Services Act, or CESA, which gives Newsom special powers during a public emergency, in this case the coronavirus pandemic, according t0 KCRA-TV.

Sutter County Judge Sarah Heckman, however, was not having any of it. She ruled on Friday that the executive order overstepped Newsom’s legal authority because he does not have the power to amend a law that already exists.

“Executive Order N-67-20 issued by the Governor on June 3, 2020 is void as an unconstitutional exercise of legislative power and shall be of no further force or effect,” Heckman’s ruling stated. “The California Emergency Services Act (CA Government Code §8550 et seq.) does not authorize or empower the Governor of the State of California to amend statutory law or make new statutory law, which is exclusively a legislative function not delegated to the Governor under the CESA.”

RELATED: Judge Limits Gavin Newsom’s Executive Order Powers – Rules His Order On Mail-In Balloting Is Unconstitutional

California Republicans Fight Newsom

This ruling came after two Republican California Assembly members, James Gallagher and Kevin Kiley, filed a lawsuit arguing that Newsom’s order exceeded his authority because he amended existing state law, which falls under the authority of the California State Assembly.

Newsom’s attorneys tried to argue that the entire issue was moot because the California Assembly later passed a similar law, but Judge Heckman disagreed. She ruled that the issue was not just about Newsom’s actions on mail-in ballots, but whether he has the power “to exercise legislative powers by unilaterally amending, altering, or changing existing statutory law or making new statutory law.”

The judge then ruled definitively that the California Emergency Services Act “does not give the Governor the power or authority to amend statutory law or create new statutory law even during a state of emergency.”

RELATED: Gov. Newsom Suggests New Coronavirus Restrictions Are Coming: ‘We Have To Enforce’

Finally, Heckman explained that Newsom’s order violated the legal doctrine of separation of powers.

“The doctrine of separation of powers prohibits any of the three branches of government exercising the complete power constitutionally vested in another or exercising power in a way which undermines the authority and independence of another,” she wrote.

This piece was written by James Samson on November 15, 2020. It originally appeared in LifeZette and is used by permission.

Read more at LifeZette:
Pelosi Goes Off On Republicans As Trump Refuses To Concede – ‘Stop The Circus And Get To Work’
OPINION: It’s Over. President Says Biden “Won.”
Justice Alito Sounds An Alarm Over Biden And PC


Recent Posts

Biden’s 2020-2021 White House Payroll – At $100.7 Million – Is Highest Ever

By Adam Andrzejewski for RealClearPolicy The payroll for White House staff under President Joseph Biden…

56 mins ago

Illinois Officials Hid That Chemicals Were In Drinking Water

By Adam Andrzejewski for RealClearPolicy Even though there were many warning signs that the drinking…

1 hour ago

10 Ways To Reduce High Energy Prices That Won’t Cost Taxpayers $740 Billion

By Bethany Blankley (The Center Square) Rather than impose higher taxes and more restrictions on…

2 hours ago

‘Some Third World Bulls***’ – Dan Bongino Goes Ballistic On Fox News Over FBI Raid of Trump’s Home

Fox News weekend host Dan Bongino, a former Secret Service agent, unleashed his anger over…

3 hours ago

Trump Speaks: Angrily Condemns ‘Political Persecution’ As FBI Raids Mar-a-Lago

Former President Donald Trump slammed never-ending "political persecution" by Democrats as he confirmed his Mar-a-Lago…

3 hours ago

DeSantis Making His Move? He’s On The Campaign Trail Supporting MAGA Candidates In Battleground States

While all eyes are focused on the 2022 midterm elections, there are some looking forward…

20 hours ago