Daily Caller

‘It’s a Civil Offense’: Democratic Congressman Falsely Claims Illegal Immigration Is Not A Crime

Jason Hopkins on November 19, 2019

  • Texas Democratic Rep. Al Green claimed during a committee hearing that illegal immigration was not a criminal act, but a civil offense.
  • Former ICE acting director Thomas Homan explained to Green that, under the Immigration and Nationality Act, unauthorized entry into the U.S. is a crime — a misdemeanor for first-time offenders and a felony for repeat offenders.
  • A growing number of Democrats, presumably more aware of immigration law, are calling for the decriminalization of illegal entry, including Sens. Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren.

A Democratic lawmaker claimed during a congressional hearing that illegal immigration is not a crime, but rather a civil offense, prompting the former chief of Immigration and Customs Enforcement to tell him otherwise.

The House Homeland Security Committee held a hearing about the Migrant Protection Protocols, a program launched by the Trump administration in January, and how it has affected those seeking asylum in the United States. Numerous Democrats blasted the program, and criticized the Trump administration’s overall approach to managing the immigration crisis.

Former acting director of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) Thomas Homan served as the only minority witness for the subcommittee hearing. While answering questions about the White House’s immigration agenda, he entered into a back-and-forth with Texas Democrat Rep. Al Green over the administration’s “zero tolerance” policy and its relation to family separation.

“The interesting thing about your argument is that these people committed no crimes,” Green said to Homan, speaking about people who lodge an asylum claim after entering the country without proper authorization.

“You enter the United States illegally, it’s a crime. It’s 8 USC — 8 United States Code 1325. It’s a crime to enter the United States illegally,” Homan quickly responded.

The Texas Democrat then claimed that unauthorized entry was not a criminal offense, saying that “It is not a crime. It’s a civil offense.” Homan, again, told to him that this claim is incorrect.

“No sir, it is not. It is a violation of criminal code Title 8 United States Code 1325 — illegal entry into the United States. The first offense is a misdemeanor. The second offense, if you’ve been ordered to remove and return, is a felony,” the former ICE chief explained.

“I agree with that,” Green said in response. “I don’t differ with you on that point.” He then brought the conversation back to the topic of family separation.

Under the Immigration and Nationality Act, unauthorized entry into the U.S. is, in fact, a crime. First time offenders are slapped with misdemeanor, which can land them up to six months in prison. The crime is upgraded to a felony for anyone who attempts to enter the country illegally more than once, and the punishment can be up to two years in prison.

A growing number of Democratic presidential candidates, aware that illegal immigration is a crime, are pushing for it to be decriminalized. Former HUD Secretary Julian Castro not only wants to see illegal immigration become a civil offense, but he’s also called for the decriminalization of illegal re-entry.

Sens. Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders have since also called for border decriminalization.

This is not the first time Homan has corrected a Democratic lawmaker on the criminality of unauthorized entry. During a congressional hearing in July, New York Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez attempted to conflate illegal entry with the legal act of claiming asylum.

“Mr. Homan, with all due respect, legal asylees are not charged with any crime,” Ocasio-Cortez said at the time. “Seeking asylum is legal.”

“If you want to seek asylum, you go through the port of entry. Do it the legal way,” Homan told Ocasio-Cortez during that July hearing.

At the end of the Homeland Security Committee hearing on Tuesday, Green requested additional speaking time to provide “clarification” about his earlier statements. The Texas Democrat suggested that he wasn’t questioning the criminality of unauthorized entry, but was arguing that claiming asylum is not illegal. He accused the Trump administration of treating asylum seekers like criminals.

Homan was not given an opportunity to respond to the statement.

Daily Caller

DCwire features investigative reporting syndicated with permission from the Daily Caller News Foundation.

View Comments

  • It is a criminal offense, indeed it should be punished much more severely in the US and rest of the world, folks like hot-shot Green ought to be "exiled" He's nothing but a bad 'alien' in disguise..and He really, with this kind of talk, does not the immigration issue any favors!👺

  • Green is as stupid as he is ugly and that is a lot! The really stupid ones are those who voted for this poor excuse of a human being.

  • I wonder if he worries about Guam capsizing like Hank Johnson? Sheesh! Where are their brains? Oh, almost forgot! They have none!.

  • Don't these democrats (and rinos) read up on the Immigration Laws of our country? Yet we elect these kind of people to political office when they don't even know the laws, nor the difference between LEGAL ans ILLEGAL?? Try this in the countries from where these ILLEGAL ALIENS originated!!

  • I would like to know what the Democrats are smoking, maybe we all should have some, illegals are not considered breaking laws?

  • Is that the same Al Green that looks exactly like every picture of a Neanderthal that you've ever seen? The one that said - "You have to impeach Trump or he'll win the next election".

  • You in Congress are supposed to work for the citizens, not illegal aliens. Crashing the border is a crime. Do you really think that if you tried what you allow on our borders anywhere else, that you would not be arrested, and imprisoned? Other countries have secure borders. It's time you stopped suckling at the money George Soros provides, and actually fulfill the oath you swore to the American citizenry. Remember, it's only one election away from oblivion.

Recent Posts

Massive Gains In GOP Voter Registration Is More Bad 2022 News For Democrats

There appears to be even more bad news looming on the horizon for Democrats this…

26 mins ago

Democrat Rep. Speier Wants States Banning Abortions To Force ‘Impregnator’ To Pay $350,000 ‘Bond’

Congresswoman Jackie Speier (D-CA), in an interview with CNN's Jim Acosta, condemned the Supreme Court's…

3 hours ago

Colorado Pregnancy Center Set On Fire, Vandalized Hours After Roe v. Wade Decision

A pregnancy center in Longmont, Colorado was vandalized with spray paint and set on fire…

3 hours ago

CIA Has Been Operating Secretly In Ukraine, Say ‘Current And Former Officials’

This week President Joe Biden is in Europe for the G-7 Summit, where discussions about…

4 hours ago

AOC Wants ‘Consequences’ For Supreme Court Justices, Impeachment For Clarence Thomas

Far-left Democrat Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (AOC) is calling for there to be "consequences" for Supreme…

5 hours ago

The Slippery Slope Of ‘Red Flag’ Gun Laws

By William Haupt III (The Center Square) "No free man shall ever be barred from…

6 hours ago