Exclusive: Labor Department To Reinstate Aide Wrongfully Accused Of Anti-Semitism
Luke Rosiak on September 4, 2019
- Trump appointee Leif Olson will return to his post after resigning following a Bloomberg Law article that falsely accused him of anti-Semitism.
- The Facebook post at issue was actually sarcastically mocking the alt-right and condemning anti-Semitism, which the full post made clear.
- Olson left the department four hours after the White House and Labor Department were contacted by reporter Ben Penn, who cropped out a portion of the post explicitly making clear that it was sarcastic.
The Department of Labor reinstated a political appointee Wednesday night who resigned under pressure after a Bloomberg Law article falsely accused him of anti-Semitism for a Facebook post in which he was actually condemning anti-Semites in the alt-right, the Daily Caller News Foundation exclusively learned.
A senior Labor Department official told the DCNF that “the acting secretary personally made this decision after carefully reviewing all the facts and circumstances. He concluded that a correction is much better than an injustice.”
Leif Olson abruptly left the department 18 days after joining the federal government, after moving his family from Texas to take the job. The departure came four hours after Bloomberg Law reporter Ben Penn contacted the White House and the Labor Department about what he portrayed as an anti-Semitic Facebook post from 2016. Penn cropped out portions of the exchange that directly referenced it being “epic sarcasm.”
“On Friday, August 30, 2019, senior policy advisor of the Wage and Hour Division Leif Olson offered his resignation and the department accepted,” the department said in a statement to the DCNF. “Following a thorough reexamination of the available information and upon reflection, the department has concluded that Olson has satisfactorily explained the tone and content of his sarcastic social media post and will return to his position.”
“What makes this one remarkable is that Olson’s Facebook page was public to his non-friends. Any cursory screening of his social media accounts could’ve uncovered the anti-Semitism,” Penn tweeted.
A cursory reading of the post showed it to be a condemnation of anti-Semitism and conspiracies on the far-right, coming from the standpoint of the center-right.
Olson resigned — apparently under pressure — within four hours of Penn emailing government officials about the post. It is unclear whether Olson’s supervisor, head of the Wage and Hour Division Cheryl Stanton, pressured him to resign and why the resignation was accepted.
Political pundits across the spectrum condemned Bloomberg and encouraged the Labor Department to reinstate Olson.
The liberal site Vox published a story titled: “How mocking anti-Semitism got a Trump official falsely accused of actual anti-Semitism. You don’t have to agree with Leif Olson’s politics to think this situation is ridiculous.”
Washington Post media critic Erik Wemple wrote there was no “excuse for Bloomberg Law reporter Ben Penn. … Those ‘anti-Semitic’ posts are plainly sarcastic, rendering them not anti-Semitic.”
Bloomberg quoted Jake Hyman, a spokesman for the Anti-Defamation League (ADL), saying “the post in question is clearly anti-Semitic.” But its unclear whether the ADL bothered to look into the matter, either. After an inquiry from the Post, the ADL said, “We appreciate Mr. Olson’s clarification that he intended to be sarcastic with his posts and accept his explanation of the content in question.”
Olson wrote a public Facebook post on Aug. 9, 2016 mocking Paul Nehlen, an anti-Semitic, alt-right candidate who challenged then-House Speaker Paul Ryan in the Wisconsin Republican primary. It said, “Establishment insider RINO corporate tool Paul Ryan was finally brought to heel in tonight’s primary election. … the guy just suffered a massive, historic, emasculating 70-point victory.”
Since, in fact, the opposite had happened — Ryan trounced Nehlen in a landslide — everything that followed could only be read as tongue-in-cheek.
When a friend played along with the sarcasm, saying Ryan is “a Jew. Everyone knows that,” Olson responded, “It must be true because I’ve never seen the Lamestream Media report it, and you know they protect their own.”
Penn apparently misinterpreted a comically exaggerated version of the far-right’s heated language to be the way a Trump appointee genuinely spoke.
Olson’s explanation was not sufficient to stop Bloomberg editors from spiking the story, in which Penn quoted Olson explaining that “It was sarcastic criticism of the alt-right’s conspiracy theories and anti-Semitic positions,” but still referred to the post as anti-Semitic.
Penn used it to paint a narrative about the Trump administration, tweeting, “This is the latest in a series of mishaps under the Trump administration personnel vetting system.”
Bloomberg declined to retract the story, in part citing that Olson was no longer working at the department as an admission of guilt.
“We stand behind our reporting,” spokesman David Peikin told the Post. “We contacted the White House and the Department of Labor asking for comment on Mr. Olson’s Facebook posts. Within four hours, the Department of Labor responded that Mr. Olson had resigned.”