Appeals Court Upholds Subpoena For Trump Accounting Records, Teeing Up Supreme Court Fight

Kevin Daley on October 11, 2019

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit upheld a subpoena for President Donald Trump’s accounting records Friday, potentially teeing up a landmark fight between the president and Congress in the Supreme Court.

The House Oversight and Government Reform Committee issued a subpoena to Mazars USA LLP after former Trump associate Michael Cohen accused the president of inflating assets and erasing liabilities on federal financial disclosures. U.S. District Judge Amit Mehta upheld the subpoena in May.

“Contrary to the president’s arguments, the committee possesses authority under both the House rules and the Constitution to issue the subpoena, and Mazars must comply,” the decision reads. Judge Neomi Rao dissented from the ruling.

House Democrats say Trump’s alleged actions raise “grave questions about potential conflicts of interest.”

The case is Trump v. Committee on Oversight and Reform of the U.S. House of Representatives.

This is breaking news. This post will be updated. 

62 thoughts on “Appeals Court Upholds Subpoena For Trump Accounting Records, Teeing Up Supreme Court Fight”

  1. The instant he announced he was running for president, he became a public figure. His refusing to release his tax returns show he’s hiding something.

    If he was caught screwing a goat, you Trumpturds would still support him.

  2. Who says he is hiding anything. His taxes aren’t anyone elses business. Obama hid everything, and liberals didn’t get all hostile over that. The only reason they have been after his tax returns is because they are hoping to come up with something, they can use to impeach him. So far they haven’t done very well. Making up lies, doesn’t count.

  3. Trump is a liar as well. When he was running for office, he promised the release his taxes many times. Then after he was elected, he said he was under audit (not a valid excuse) and soon it was over, he would release them (2 years ago!!). What is Trump so scared of, the truth? Money laundering, Russian loans, fraud, cheating? He controls the Treasury Department (Mnuchin is one of his mob thugs) and the IRS, and he is capable of massive cheating and crime on his taxes. He knows he is finished if his taxes are released.

  4. Guess what, this is and Obama appointed judge and this judge has it out for Trump……go figure!!!……and the stupid lawyer is Cohen who also has it out for Trump!!!

  5. Exactly right it’s none of their business anything to get under Trump skin that’s all they’re trying to do,, more Democrat left the bull crap unbelievable disgusting actions.

  6. Of course it is a witch hunt. But what is laughable is the way YOU insist on using taxes as a tool. Americans like you are IGNORANT! You claim that we should base our decisions on the truth while at the same time pushing the fraud and lies of the left. Personal Income Tax is a FRAUD!!!! Even the Supreme Court ruled, decades ago, that wages an income from ones labor cannot be taxed! Filing a tax form is VOLUNTARY! There is NO LAW requiring paying income tax. The government ha you poor ignorant fools completely indoctrinated!
    There are several truths about income tax:
    1) The 16th amendment was NEVER legally ratified by the require number of states! By the way, Congress cannot pass an amendment that violates the Constitution, yet they did it anyways!
    2) The Supreme Court ruled that it is unconstitutional, thereby illegal, to tax income.
    3) The IRS cannot show you the law because it does not exist!
    Want proof? Watch this — here is the ex-IRS commissioner proving it to be a lie. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nX-03Sf1wDo&t=119s

  7. Funny how it was ok for Obama to hide not only his taxes but his nationality as he blocked all of the same info as they are asking Trump. This government is so corrupt that we need to fire them all . If Trumphas to show all info , I want Hitlery and Pelosi to do the same.

  8. He is not as stupid as you think, and this will open up the whole government to the very same scrutiny. I cannot wait for all to see he has nothing to hide. But then when we see the whole case of the Clintons, from Benghazi to Uranium deal with Russia and taking payment for our Uranium stock pile she sold to Russia and pocketed the money, it’s going to backfire and show the American people that your beloved pathetic Clintons are going to open up a can of worms that every democrat will fear . Personally I’m gonna enjoy the repercussions of this. Hahahahhahahah. Every puke Dem politicians are going to want to quit politics and will eventually be moving to GITMO for the tirade they are going to bring on themselves. Ever heard of what goes around comes back 10 fold. I’m laughing so hard when I see trolls like you spouting off because it’s going to show everyone how corrupt the Dems are and have been. I am sure they will find the billions of dollars that went missing when Obama left office. That was a total corrupt cabinet that has all of this going on in the first place. So careful what YOU wish for. It’s going to be a bitter pill to swallow once it actually happens and it WILL SHOW ALL VOTERS WHO DEMS REALLY ARE.

  9. This is all a smokescreen for Dems to hide all corruption they are all about. It’s all about what is good for Trump also opens the law up to Clinton, Pelosi, and so many. But especially BIDEN who was the real reason this whole issue is being played out. It’s all about making DEMS IOPEN UP THEIR CORRUPT WAYS TO THE WORKLD. The old saying . What goes around,comes back to them 10 fold. It’s funny how Anthony Weiner became the hero for the cleaning up and destroying the DEEP STATE. Those who do t understand what is really going on, know how this is going to put Clinton, Obama and,the rest of those corrupt politicians who have cheated we the people out of jobs, businesses, and it’s going to come back into their faces so hard they,won’t have time to fix those records like they,are going to have to do to keep from being caught stealing from our middle class who has to pay for every single corrupt democrat that thinks it’s going to get away with cheating this country out of every dime they have stolen innjust the previous administration. Uranium 1 is going to be the end of the tyrant Hitlery

  10. Olive, DEMS DONT READ. THEY JUST REPEAT ANYTHING,TO GET MORE FREEBIES FROM DEM POLITICIANS AND,DONT WANT TO HEAR ANYTHING GOOD FROM ANYONE UNLESS ITMGIVES THEM MORE WELFARE.

  11. Actually, it’s going to put the Dems right where the Republicans want them. Dems just passed a law that will also be the end of so many democrats who think the smokescreen is only going to affect TRUMP, when it actually is all about making Dems get all the interrogatories asked for since Obama was first elected. See they also are now by law having to show the very same of anything that,causes them to WELCOME GITMO , once they are forced to do the very same. Ruby Guilliani is not stupid. He knows exactly who wishes to not disclose anything they have done, because this is really all about transparency that Dems have so much more to hide then Trump, and Biden is the cause of it all with him and his son doing the bidding with Ukraine. So, let’s have some fun. Watch who really,feels this pain. It won’t be Trump. I can,promise you that. Bahahahahahhahah. It’s going,to be all records opened about Clinton.and Obama, Pelosi and all who are in Anthony Weiners computer. No more excuses, time to get,all the trash out of our government. Just you wait and see. It’s going,to be like dominos all falling at once.

  12. This is all about a partisan Dim D.A. from New York City that is trying to make a name for himself and possibly set himself up for a run at New York Mayor or Senator. What he doesn’t know is the power of POTUS to dig up dirt on him. He wont be able to win dogcatcher after Trump gets through with him.

  13. There is no law that says Presidents must show their taxes. The previous presidents did it VOLUNTARILY. With the TDS that consumes the house it is obvious that they are searching for something to remove a President who WAS LEGALLY VOTED IN BY 50% of AMERICANS. What do you ou think will happen if the Dems succeed? THERE WILL BE A CIVIL WAR.

  14. Pelosi loves to say that, but she actually only means no conservatives. If she really meant no one, she would be investigated along with Obama, Hilary, Comey, Biden, Strozk, Lynch, Waters, Warren, Schumer, Cummings, and many other corrupt liberal socialists.

  15. “If we couldn’t find crimes with Mueller maybe Ukraine will give us something, drat nothing… Well we still have the call for his financial records, oops, well maybe not…” When will these people learn they are not dealing with the usual wishy washy Republicans, but someone who fights back and even takes a wack first.. About time..

  16. Even Trump has nothing to worry about, it’s goingmto backfire and if Trump shows his taxes, so will The Real Crooks od DC. Clinton, Obama, Pelosi, and the rest should be running for the,hills. It’s going,to be a real shame to see Dems have to own up to all their wrongdoings, because this just opened up a can of worms for the Dems . They are going to be running for the hills. But in,the end, Trump is doing what he was elected to do. Clean up the swamp and bring. Everyone to justice.

  17. Olive, it’s all really about Obama himself and all records that will be expected of them as well. Actually think that this was a way to clean out the swamp fast. Watch,how many Dems are forced to show anything about themselves. Trump doesn’t have a thing to worry about, but he knows it’s going,to scare so many Dems that they won’t be a party anymore. They are the ones who have real things to hide, like right down to murder. Biden,with Ukraine is the first to be showing Dem voters how corrupt their party really is. This is actually good news for Republicans

  18. If you are a “DEMOCRAT” You need to look at what the Bloomberg & Soros “NEW WORLD ORDER?|” aka “ONE WORLD ” organization of which OWNS that Democratic party you like so much is doing to our country.
    These are a group of world billionaires that want to control the WORLD. Just look at the power they acquired already to push the agenda to disarm America – WHY? Because they know they can never control an armed population.
    They own or control almost “ALL” news media and the news can only tell what the N.W.O. want you to believe weather it is true or not.
    Destroy our President with any lie they can come up with.

  19. There’s no rule that says President Trump has to show his damn financial records to be president . This is a Democrat action to undermine the election and the votes of the Americans that voted for Trump for President of the United States of America !!!

  20. Yep another Obama appointed leftist radical judge,, if a judge will take a look at Obama’s records which he hasn’t produced or real birth certificate not that imposter he showed everybody he may wind up in jail and banished from the United States that would be great the worst president in the history of the world Obama.

  21. Why does the “need” of Trump hating, democrat, political opposition…have the power to circumvent the 4th and 5th amendments to the constitution. The I.R.S. has it’s own method and all the agents it needs to investigate anyone who has done something illegal on a tax return? The democrats can’t find anything with which to impeach Trump, so they want to go looking through 4th and 5th amendment protected materials, to see if they can dig up something, ANYTHING that they could characterize or interpret as having the appearance of impropriety. They’ve already demonstrated a remarkable ability to lie through their teeth and capable of anything via their hate for a successful presidency, that they themselves have never been able to deliver.

  22. All politicians on both sides should have to release their tax returns. I for one am very tired of all the con artists, mobster dealing crooks in office saying they represent me, when they don’t have a clue what it’s like to work a real job or what the majority of Americans have to deal with in their daily lives. Shouldn’t be a problem if they have nothing to hide. Maybe this way we can get some honest hard working people in office, instead of those who want to use it to their advantage to keep the status quo.

  23. You are correct. What they want the financial records for is a fishing expedition to try and uncover any violation of any law; even obscure ones, so they can add it to their impeachment scam.

  24. You are 100% correct. Look what is happening today. Rudy Jiuliana has two friends from the Ukraine who were helping him in get the information on the Bidens and what happens? The Establishment are accusing them of money laundering and other crimes; remember, Democrats are experts at accusing everyone else of doing what they are actually doing. How can anyone with any integrity be a Democrat?

  25. Never. The Establishment will protect Obama til the day he dies. There are at least two reasons for this. Obama is a minority, and he is a Democrat. Neither of these are reason to prosecute in the present day society in the USA. Sad, but true.

  26. Don’t tell John Roberts, he is still under the illusion that judges are not biased and they make rulings based on the law; Wow! Is he ever naïve? He should never be the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court. In fact, because he re-wrote the worse law to ever be passed by a partisan Democrat Party, ACA (ObamaCare) to make it legal and thus violating his oath of office, he should be impeached and thrown off the supreme court. The Democrats who wrote this very bad law told the world that the Mandate was a penalty. But Roberts re-wrote the law to make it a tax.

  27. It actually goes “…by whatever standard of measure you use to judge you shall be judged by that same measure” (standard). Its not forbidden to judge another but we are to do so wisely and based on good standards. However, grace is far better than judgement.

  28. This is just another witch hunt. It is none of the Democrats business how Much money any POTUS made before he was elected president. They need to look closer in their field for those who did not pay taxes and owes the government money such as Al Sharpton who owes thousands, I am sure Hillary Clinton and Bill Clinton made money Illegally and other Democrats Obama ???? , Biden ????, Just to name a few. So if they are doing it to Trump now. Then The Democrats needs to request tax papers for 5 years and after all POTUS’s left office.

  29. None of anyone business about his finances or taxes. Demdummys just are scared of getting him reelected and coming out with all their dirty dealings and criminal activies in the past. He is not an Dem. player and he swore to up hold the law and get the deep state. So they will bring up anything to get him. But the sad thing is a lot of people are believing them and not looking at facts. I guess the dems are right FACTS dont matter when their future is at steak

  30. Barack Obama aka Barry Soetoro the usurper FRAUD, when will he be FORCED to UN-seal his RECORDS, then go to prison, then be deported to Indonesia or KENYA and be banished from USA forever?

  31. Pelosi said no one is above the law. Does that include all the crooked democracs too. Your lyes will tell on you. Pelosi needs to remember, judge not for you shall be judged. God said that and he does not lye.

  32. Gold, you might be better believed if you could write coherently and accurately, as well as spell correctly. Before you call anyone inane names, improve yourself.
    OUR PRESIDENT is well within his right not to show his taxes – there is no law requiring it. “Requirements for the President of the United States
    George Washington, first president of the United States
    Legal requirements for presidential candidates have remained the same since the year Washington accepted the presidency. As directed by the Constitution, a presidential candidate must be a natural born citizen of the United States, a resident for 14 years, and 35 years of age or older.”
    If you want a picture of his financial situation, look at the entire financial disclosure package each and every candidate must submit prior to being put on a ballot. It covers everything and anything, loans, properties, mortgages, credit cards, income, insurances, bank accounts, stocks/portfolios, IRAs, etc., etc.. The only thing they don’t ask for is what one has had for breakfast. You nor anyone else needs to see anyone’s income tax returns – that is against the law.

  33. There is no law that mandates that anyone has to show their taxes. You Dems are on a fishing expedition for any dirt you can get on Trump and make it into your fantasy world facts. Give it a rest and stop being a lemming. Learn to seek the facts.

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top