By Dr. Derek Ellerman
Poor Vivek Ramaswamy is, at least for the moment, one of those unfortunate victims of time and circumstance.
Experience The Political Insider without ads
In any other era, I would consider the long-shot Republican presidential candidate to at least be interesting enough to follow, maybe even support.
Yesterday, Ramaswamy dropped another good idea that does have my full attention: He wants to amend the Constitution to raise the voting age from 18 to 25.
Yes, Yes, and Hell Yes.
The Constitution does not expressly *guarantee* universal voting. This is intentional: we live in a Constitutional republic, not a direct democracy. The 14th Amendment specifically distinguishes the immunities of citizenship from the privileges of citizenship. Voting is a… pic.twitter.com/tx4nbZHGv5
— Vivek Ramaswamy (@VivekGRamaswamy) May 12, 2023
Experience The Political Insider without ads
Raise The Voting Age
Ordinarily, I’m a proponent of just one single age of majority. I’m not necessarily hung up on exactly what age that is, but it should be uniform.
If someone is a legal adult, they should have all the rights and responsibilities of an adult; buying cigarettes, buying alcohol, buying a firearm, full legal responsibility, being able to rent a car, join the military, etc.
These days, there’s a dizzying amount of proposals all over the country to raise this or that minimum age requirement for this or that activity. If someone is an adult at 18, why would they need to wait another three years to purchase a handgun?
I think most rational people view it as not only ludicrous, but plainly immoral to tell an 18-year-old they have to suit up and go fire a 155mm howitzer at strangers in some far-off land, but they can’t buy a little pistol or drink a beer.
Nobody, anywhere, should have to move on to the next life without a sip of the sweet nectar.
Support Conservative Voices!
Sign up to receive the latest political news, insight, and commentary delivered directly to your inbox.
But I’m on a little bit of a rant here. Vivek Ramaswamy’s proposal, which he unveiled during a campaign stop in Iowa, would do two things. Raise the voting age to 25, but also allow people 18-25 to vote if they either do six months in the military or as a first responder or if they pass the citizenship test.
Ramaswamy described his reasoning thusly: “I think it is a problem that young people don’t vote enough in this country. But if you make it something that you actually have to earn, you value it even more. It’s human nature and psychology.”
Fair, and true, as far as it goes.
I’m fully two-thirds in favor of this proposal and I’ll tell you why.
The youngest guy in the audience tonight had a reaction to my proposed constitutional amendment that requires 18-year-olds to pass a civics test or else to meet a national service requirement. Pretty inspiring. pic.twitter.com/gkNUb8WQ3O
— Vivek Ramaswamy (@VivekGRamaswamy) May 12, 2023
Experience The Political Insider without ads
Young People Are Dumb
Of Ramaswamy’s proposal, I would only nix the “national service” requirement part. Not because it’s necessarily a bad idea or that it wouldn’t have a positive impact on citizenship a la Starship Troopers, but because we probably don’t want a sudden bubble of millions of new government employees with nothing to do.
Experience The Political Insider without ads
Idle hands, and all.
As for raising the voting age, other than my own internal cognitive dissonance at backtracking on everything I just said about one uniform age of majority, it’s a must.
You only need one reason, too. Look at public school test scores.
Experience The Political Insider without ads
American kids can’t even read. Let’s just stop right there. We could go down the whole laundry list – they can’t do math, they aren’t taught and therefore know next to nothing about history, etc – but we don’t need to.
Let’s just agree that we don’t need to go farther.
In a democracy, every voter counts as much as any other. It doesn’t matter if the kid in the booth next to you can’t read. He still has the same amount of power. He can still vote for wanton criminality, theft, disastrous foreign adventurism, etc.
That is the entire problem with democracy. People with no skin in the game still get a say. Malicious actors get the same say as you. Oh, you spent hours researching where your Congressman stands on IMF debt restructuring? That dumb kid got an instruction on who to vote for from a professor.
Experience The Political Insider without ads
Experience The Political Insider without ads
You work 60 hours a week only to have half your paycheck stolen for Ukraine’s border or cellphones for illegal aliens? That dumb kid didn’t work for a minute, and he just voted to increase spending to Ukraine. Doesn’t matter that he couldn’t tell you what continent it’s on to save his immortal soul. That vote counts as much as yours.
Maybe you can see where I’m going with this. Democracy is stupid. Very, very stupid. Unless there are guardrails.
Now don’t worry, the Earth will be a burnt crisp falling into the sun before I ever get my way about democracy. But the above still makes the case that, so long as people are exercising such an enormous amount of power – and power, my friends, is force – we should at least make attempts to ensure voters have a bare minimum of knowledge and life experience to make such heady decisions.
I don’t have enough space here, but my final argument is just two words: Gen Z.
Experience The Political Insider without ads
The Constitution was already amended to lower the voting age from 21 to 18. It can be amended again.
And when schools start teaching kids things besides drag queen story hour, we can think about an amendment to lower it back to 18.
Now is the time to support and share the sources you trust.
The Political Insider ranks #3 on Feedspot’s “100 Best Political Blogs and Websites.”
Read this Next on ThePoliticalInsider.com
Mayorkas Stops Briefing to Correct Reporter April Ryan After She Tries to Revive False ‘Whipping’ Story About Haitian Migrants
Leave a Comment
COMMENTS POLICY: We have no tolerance for messages of violence, racism, vulgarity, obscenity or other such discourteous behavior. Thank you for contributing to a respectful and useful online dialogue.
All 18 year olds are eligible for military service, are considered adults in both criminal and civil court, and can vote. A male must register for the selective service. There are no partial adults. 18 year olds should have every right as does any other adult.
No, the voting age should not be raised. Moreover, 18 year olds should be allowed to have every adult right/privilege, such as alcohol, tobacco, etc. Signed old guy.
Absolute nonsense. At age 77 I can assure you that you only begin to understand the ins ands outs of society one you reach the age of 65.
If you want to raise the voting age do it properly, no one below 65 should have the vote!
PS Heinlein in Starship Troopers wrote of a society where only “Veterans” could vote. Anyone and everyone could sign up for 5 (or more) years of hardship and sacrifice in the military. The rationale being that unless you are wiling to put your life on the line for a society, you should not have a say in how it is run.
Not only should the voting are be raised to 25, but I also believe voters should be land owners.
Since most at the age of 18 have no real world experience and are brainwashed in schools that try to blend in socialism as the consistently dumb down the students, 25 may sound high for a voting age but it’s more realistic than one thinks…..Nothing like getting into the real world to find out how much the gov demands from your paycheck for them to squander….We could remove unions from the private sector, follow the law and remove illegal unions from government, remove the IRS for domestic progressive taxes and resort to oversighted consumption taxes where everyone pays taxes…..no more yearly tax anxiety….If this appeals to you talk about it more and make it happen…..