Atlantic Editor Admits A Key Claim In Trump Hit Piece Could Be Wrong

Editor’s Note: The headline has been updated to make it clear that Jeffrey Goldberg’s admission related specifically to first-hand accounts which contradict The Atlantic’s claim that President Trump lied about weather being the cause of his 2018 cancelled visit to Aisne-Marne American Cemetery. More of The Atlantic editor Jeffrey Goldberg’s quote from the CNN interview has also been added for context.

Jeffrey Goldberg, Editor-in-Chief for The Atlantic, confessed that the central claim in his publication’s reprehensible hit piece on the President could very well be false.

The Atlantic column starts off with a claim that the President did not want to visit the Aisne-Marne American Cemetery near Paris in 2018, because “his hair would become disheveled in the rain” and that “he did not believe it important to honor American war dead.”

Remember – this is the lede to the piece and sets up every other argument throughout, like the claim that Trump despises the military and veterans, and referred to them as “suckers” and “losers.”

Goldberg’s acceptance of Bolton’s account means that the claim by his four, off-the-record, anonymous sources that the visit was called off for any reason other than weather may not be correct.

When presented with an excerpt from former national security adviser John Bolton’s book which details how the weather was the cause for cancellation of the visit to the cemetery, not a decision by POTUS over his hair, Goldberg conceded, “I’m sure all of those things are true.”

RELATED: John Bolton: Claims That Trump Disparaged Fallen Soldiers Are ‘Simply False’

Goldberg Still Stands By His Reporting

Not only did Bolton inadvertently provide evidence that Goldberg’s ‘Swift Boat’ attempt of the President was factually incorrect in at least this one aspect, but he followed up in a subsequent interview with Fox News to reiterate the story was false.

“According to what that article said, the president made disparaging remarks about soldiers and people buried in the cemetery in connection with the decision for him not to go to the ceremony that was planned that afternoon,” Bolton stated, “and that was simply false.”

He continued, “I don’t know who told the author that, but that was false.”

The central claim of the story is certifiably fake news, and the American people are supposed to believe the other things your anonymous sources said? That’s not how this works.

Still, Goldberg is standing by the bulk of the story. While he acknowledged that Bolton’s counterclaim about the weather cancellation was true, Goldberg went on to add:

“I’ve heard from people in the Pentagon who, Marines, who are a bit insulted that the idea that the Marines couldn’t fly a helicopter in the rain.

“But the larger point is, is that Donald Trump expressed directly to senior aides his lack of desire to go to the cemetery and not to risk 90 minutes in traffic because he doesn’t understand why one would go pay that level of respect to fallen American soldiers.”

CNN asked the Editor to respond to President Trump’s denials that the comments were ever made.

“I would be willing to swear on anything that I never said that about our fallen heroes,” the President said. “There is nobody that respects them more. So, I just think it’s a horrible, horrible thing.”

He added, “What animal would say such a thing?”

Goldberg replied, “Uh, I stand by my reporting. I have multiple sources saying this is what happened, so I stand by it.”

RELATED: John Bolton’s Book Refutes Claims In Anonymously Sourced Atlantic Hit Piece Against Trump

About Those Sources

Goldberg can stand by those sources all he wants, but it says something about his journalistic integrity that he is willing to run a story based on accounts from four anonymous sources instead of actually researching their claims.

Claims that, by now, have been denied by 21 people overall, and over a dozen who had first-hand knowledge of events that took place during the trip in question.

The Atlantic has four nameless sources, while the President has the following backing him up:

  • John Bolton (see above and the excerpt from his book).

  • Zach Fuentes, Former White House Deputy Chief of Staff to Gen. John Kelly: “I don’t know who the sources are,” Fuentes told Breitbart News. “I did not hear POTUS call anyone losers when I told him about the weather. Honestly, do you think General Kelly would have stood by and let ANYONE call fallen Marines losers?”
  • Sarah Huckabee Sanders, Former White House Press Secretary:

  • Lt. General Keith Kellogg (Ret.), National Security Adviser for Vice President Pence: “The Atlantic story is completely false. Absolutely lacks merit. I’ve been by the President’s side. He has always shown the highest respect to our active duty troops and veterans with utmost respect paid to those who have given the ultimate sacrifice and those wounded in battle.”
  • Hogan Gidley, Former White House Deputy Press Secretary:

  • Dan Scavino, White House Deputy Chief of Staff for Communications:

  • Jordan Karem, Former Personal Aide to President Trump:

  • Stephen Miller, White House Senior Advisor: The Atlantic story is a “despicable lie” and “the president deeply wanted to attend the memorial event in question and was deeply displeased by the bad weather call.”
  • First Lady Melania Trump:

  • Dan Walsh, Former White House Deputy Chief of Staff: “I can attest to the fact that there was a bad weather call in France, and that the helicopters were unable to safely make the flight.”
  • Derek Lyons, Staff Secretary and Counselor to the President: “I was with the President the morning after the scheduled visit. He was extremely disappointed that arrangements could not be made to get him to the site, and that the trip had been cancelled.”
  • Johnny DeStefano, Former Counselor to the President:

  • Tony Ornato, White House Deputy Chief of Staff and Former Secret Service Special Agent in Charge of the Presidential Protective Division:

  • U.S. Ambassador to France and Monaco Jamie McCourt: “In my presence, POTUS has NEVER denigrated any member of the U.S. military or anyone in service to our country. And he certainly did not that day, either. Let me add, he was devastated to not be able to go to the cemetery at Belleau Wood. In fact, the next day, he attended and spoke at the ceremony in Suresnes in the pouring rain.”

  • Mark Meadows, White House Chief of Staff:

  • Kayleigh McEnany, White House Press Secretary:

  • Judd Deere, Deputy Press Secretary for President Trump:

  • Mick Mulvaney, Former Acting White House Chief of Staff:

  • Alyssa Farah, White House Communications Director:

  • Nick Ayers, Former Chief of Staff to Vice President Mike Pence:

  • Major General (ret.) Bill Matz, Secretary of the American Battle Monuments Commission:

At least fourteen of the aforementioned people were on the trip in which these anonymous sources claim the President disparaged veterans.

In a perfect world, the Trump administration wouldn’t need to publish so many denials of the story.

In a perfect world, the left-leaning, pro-Biden media would instead be fair, impartial, and balanced in their reporting, never running a story with so many holes in it from so many weak sources.

Rusty Weiss

Rusty Weiss is a freelance writer focusing on the conservative movement and its political agenda. He has been following and analyzing the political climate for several years, and his writings have appeared in the Daily Caller, FoxNews.com and more.

View Comments

  • This guy got caught, and didn't expect such a backlash...so he caved! A very happy ending to this FAKE NEWS attempt at smearing Trump so close to the election...

  • They’re able to do that because they know the media will not call them out for it. Hell the media spews the lies themselves.

  • This fake Journalist is willing to take the word of people who don't have 
    the Balls to go public they would rather hide in the sewers like RATS and 
    spread Lies. It's Time that The President took a page from Nick Sandman 
    and started suing these fake Journalist and their Fake news outlets and 
    put them out of Business. I realize the President doesn't need the money 
    He would win from these Law suet's He could donate it to Tunnels to Towers 
    which would make the Fake News gang's collective Heads Explode.

  • The sad part is many people will remember the negative impression of this false report, even though it may be retracted. the liberal media know this and its why you hear so many lies from them, they count on people remembering the negative, even if proven false later on. its not about fair reporting, its all about their 'agenda'.

  • I think Jonah Goldberg is one of the most despicable and worthless excuses for a journalist who exists. Last week, I was verbally harassed by a coworker who is utterly convinced of this story because "Jonah Goldberg is a journalist and everything can't be fake news". Normally, I get along fine with my coworker, but thanks to these leftists, my coworker has become a raving Trump hater to the point of making things tense on the job.

Recent Posts

The ‘American Century’ is Over. Our Politicians Killed It.

For a little over a hundred years, the United States and its dearest friends across…

4 hours ago

Press Secretary for Dem AZ Governor Katie Hobbs Resigns After Posting Tweet Encouraging Shooting ‘Transphobes’

Josselyn Berry, a top aide for Democrat Governor of Arizona, Katie Hobbs, has resigned following…

5 hours ago

Another ‘Trump Indictment’ On the Ropes? Manhattan DA Alvin Bragg Taking a Month Off

By Dr. Derek Ellerman Oh, dear reader, how many times now?  How many times have…

6 hours ago

Tucker Carlson Explains Why Nashville School Shooter’s Manifesto Is Being Hidden: ‘It’s Not Accidental’

Fox News personality Tucker Carlson argued that the manifesto written by the Nashville elementary shooter…

7 hours ago

Cruz to Mayorkas: ‘If You Had Integrity, You Would Resign’

By Bethany Blankley (The Center Square) After repeatedly refusing to answer questions and not knowing…

8 hours ago

Marjorie Taylor Greene Accuses Twitter of ‘Whitewashing Trans-Terrorism’ After Her Account Was Locked

Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene called out Twitter chief Elon Musk for "whitewashing" political violence in…

8 hours ago