Chris White on June 24, 2019
- A new undercover video from Project Veritas shows a Google executive claiming that busting up big tech companies will make it more difficult to prevent “the next Trump situation.”
- The executive also called Sen. Elizabeth Warren’s willingness to break up Silicon Valley “misguided” before praising the Massachusetts Democrat.
- The executive also revealed the reason why Google decided not to show up at congressional hearings in 2018 discussing what social media companies should do about misinformation.
A Google executive suggested in an undercover video from Project Veritas that breaking up the company will make it more difficult for tech companies to moderate social media platforms.
Breaking up Google will make smaller tech companies responsible for moderating content before elections, Jen Gennai, a veteran Google executive, said in a video PV published Monday morning. The report also contained comments from an alleged Google insider claiming the company is not an objective source of information.
“Elizabeth Warren is saying we should break up Google,” she said, referring to the Massachusetts Democrat’s wish to break up big tech. The senator wants to impose new rules on tech companies with $25 billion or more in annual ad revenue, forcing Amazon and Google to dramatically reduce their hold on online commerce.
“And like, I love her but she’s very misguided, like that will not make it better it will make it worse, because all these smaller companies who don’t have the same resources that we do will be charged with preventing the next Trump situation, it’s like a small company cannot do that,” Gennai added.
It is not apparent from the video whether Gennai, who is head of responsible innovation at Google, is referring to ways the company can prevent President Donald Trump’s reelection or stave off the conditions before the 2020 election. Google and Facebook have been pressured to do more to clean up their platforms ever since Trump’s win.
She also brought up Google’s reluctance to address Congress.
“We got called in front of Congress multiple times, so we’ve not shown up because we know that they’re just going to attack us,” Gennai said in the video, which is heavily edited and does not include her full comments.”We’re not going to change our, we’re not going to change our mind.”
She was referring to Google’s decision in 2018 not to send a representative to a congressional hearing about . Google is committed to moving forward on content moderation, she added.
Google has not responded to the Daily Caller News Foundation’s request for comment about Gennai’s comments. PV spokesman Marco Bruno directed the DCNF to the alleged Google insider’s comments suggesting that the company “is not an objective source of information.”
The video is part of a report PV published that also contains snippets of an interview with an alleged Google whistleblower, who provides context to what Gennai is saying at various parts of the undercover video. The insider claims at one point that the company is using an algorithm called Machine Learning Fairness to push a political agenda.
Conservatives argue that big tech companies are biased against them — only 9% of San Francisco residents voted for Trump, while some reports show that ex-Facebook contractors who worked on news curation revealed in 2016 that they suppressed articles expressing conservative views.
The company is also being scrutinized for manipulating search results. Two company policies dubbed the “misrepresentation policy” and the “good neighbor policy” inform the company’s news blacklist, the Daily Caller reported in April. The purpose of the blacklist is to bar sites from surfacing in news products, according to documents the Caller obtained.
PV’s report and undercover video come as Republicans and Democrats are considering antitrust investigations targeting big tech. Democratic Rep. David Cicilline of Rhode Island announced plans on June 3 that congress will begin a probe determining whether big tech companies are acting as a monopoly.
The investigation comes several days after a Wall Street Journal report noted the Department of Justice is preparing an antitrust probe against Google’s search engine and business model. It would be the first such investigation since the Federal Trade Commission conducted a probe of Google but closed it in 2013 without taking action.