In the world of satire, there’s a concept known as “Poe’s Law,” which describes satire so accurate that it’s indistinguishable from what it’s mocking. Little did CRTV’s Allie Stuckey know she could (accidentally) accomplish such a feat.
After the new liberal darling Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez bombed an interview on PBS’ “The Firing Line” with Margaret Hoover, Stuckey threw together a satirical “mock interview” using clips from the “Firing Line” episode. In the video, Stuckley asks a fictitious Cortez a number of questions, with Cortez’s responses being cut from the Firing Line interview. Cortez’s “responses” are humorously bad, and Stuckey never intended for anyone to take the video seriously.
The video was funny, and it’s obvious to everyone in their right mind watching it that it’s a piece of satire. But little did Stuckey know that the interview looked real…. to liberals! Apparently, under the impression that the video you’re about to watch could actually be considered real, liberals have fired back that it’s “fake news” aimed to “discredit Cortez.”
You can watch the obviously satirical video below:
Enlightening & hard-hitting interview with Socialist “it girl” and fellow millennial, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. pic.twitter.com/4txoxwqql6
— Allie Beth Stuckey (@conservmillen) July 23, 2018
But thanks to our journalists and pundits on the left, they’ve confirmed for the rest of us that the video above is indeed satire (just wait until next week, when they confirm that two plus two does indeed equal four!).
Sharia-law enthusiast Linda Sarsour had the following comment:
#FakeNews like it’s actually really fake and doctored. #desperation https://t.co/AsB923zN7s
— Linda Sarsour (@lsarsour) July 24, 2018
And Cortez herself weighed in, citing this as evidence that Republicans are so scared of her that they’re faking videos. By that logic, I guess everyone on Saturday Night Live fears Trump.
Republicans are so scared of me that they’re faking videos and presenting them as real on Facebook because they can’t deal with reality anymore.
Here’s one bonafide truth:
Election Day is November 6th. https://t.co/Z7MfisgiWl— Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (@Ocasio2018) July 24, 2018
BuzzFeed also provided an unnecessary debunking of the video’s quality, I suppose because they were all out of listicles to write for the day.
https://twitter.com/JaneLytv/status/1021790418286125057
Of course, anyone who saw the real Cortez interview that this Stuckley satire is taking clips from knows that the “real” interview wasn’t much better. At one point, Cortez claimed that the unemployment rate was only as low as it is because “everyone is working two jobs.”
Not only is the percentage of Americans working 2 jobs at the lowest point in American history, having more than one job has no effect on the unemployment rate (because a person’s employment status is binary. They’re either employed or they’re not). She also made a number of anti-Israel comments before admitting she doesn’t know anything about the Middle East.
Refreshingly, most did understand that the video was satire.
If u thought this video was anything other than an obvious troll then ur a dumbass who shouldn’t be running for office pic.twitter.com/7TrXElxCDp
— Pardes Seleh (@PardesSeleh) July 24, 2018
Fact Check: .@conservmillen did NOT present the interview as “real.” It was obviously satire. Hilarious, accurate satire. https://t.co/86UbWoo8Xf
— Eddie Zipperer (@EddieZipperer) July 24, 2018
It was an obvious joke, anyone who thinks that video is real should go see an ENT ASP. https://t.co/0vbyfRyqNo
— The Reagan Battalion (@ReaganBattalion) July 24, 2018
Hip millennial candidate unaware with concept of "satire" https://t.co/laLBQwlmwI
— Matt Palumbo (@MattPalumbo12) July 24, 2018
Good Lord I cannot believe people are seriously pretending they didn't know this was fake. I do not believe for one second that these people are that gullible. If they are, that's kind of sad.
— Doctor Bringus (@DoctorBringus) July 24, 2018
Anyone who thinks it was real shouldn't be on the internet without adult supervision to begin with
— Alexander Rushov (@Rushovalexander) July 24, 2018
Eventually, Stuckley responded directly to Cortez with a clarification she wouldn’t have to make in a sane world.
To the few saying: “THIS IS FAKE!”
Thank you! I don’t know where any of us would be without your keen insight. As much as we hoped no one would notice that this is *literally taken from a PBS interview she did last week and was edited together as a joke*, the jig is up I guess. https://t.co/rnm3TPNy3i
— Allie Beth Stuckey (@conservmillen) July 24, 2018
Lol. ??♂️ It was never presented as real. The *entire point* was for it to look edited. We don’t have to say “SATIRE” just so people who don’t notice that we clearly spliced her PBS interview to make a comedic point can feel okay. https://t.co/K8jbiCnrth
— Allie Beth Stuckey (@conservmillen) July 24, 2018
Girl— it was a clear joke, not a “fake” video. :) As much as I disagree with you politically, I’ve been public about how impressed I am with your quick rise to prominence. Good luck! https://t.co/CsXByCbGJO
— Allie Beth Stuckey (@conservmillen) July 24, 2018
Hopefully, Cortez and her ilk don’t go anywhere soon. In actively promoting her, it’s evident that Democrats haven’t gotten tired of losing elections just yet.